Paralegal Mark Anthony Given has spent four years hand collecting every winning criminal case in the history of the Montana Supreme Court. A Montana Criminal Defense Attorney can find here in 15 minutes what would take days or even weeks to locate. This is a sample of the over 1,000 available winning cases, the rest will be available soon via pay site.

Wednesday, May 21, 2008

we hold that the District Court exceeded its statutory authority by

2001 MT 101
STATE OF MONTANA,v.
ROBERT SETTERS,

The issues on appeal are:
1. Whether the District Court erred in requiring Setters to pay restitution.
2. Whether the District Court properly considered Setters' ability to pay when it
established the amount of restitution.
3. Whether the District Court erred in assessing a penalty in addition to restitution.
Section 46-18-202(1)(e), MCA (1997), provides that a sentencing court may impose
any condition or restriction "reasonably related to the objectives of rehabilitation and the protection of the victim and society." However, in interpreting that provision in State v. Ommundson, 1999 MT 16, , 293 Mont. 133, 974 P.2d 620, we held that a sentencing limitation or condition must have some correlation or connection to the
underlying offense for which the defendant is being sentenced. There is no suchcorrelation or connection in this case between Setters' conviction on the tampering charge and ordering him to pay restitution to DPHHS for his alleged theft of public assistance benefits. Consequently, the District Court's order did not meet the statutory requirements for the imposition of restitution on a suspended sentence.
Accordingly, we hold that the District Court exceeded its statutory authority by
ordering Setters to pay restitution for a dismissed count as a condition of his sentence.
Hence, we reverse the determination of the District Court as to restitution and we order that portion of Setters' sentence vacated.

No comments:

Blog Archive

About Me

My photo
Given was raised on the streets and in foster homes surrounded by twelve girls. By age 11, authorities already warned his foster mother: “He’s too smart for his britches — keep an eye on him.” That early spark of genius — later estimated in the 145–155+ IQ range (top 0.1% to 0.01% of humanity) — combined with an elite, poetic vocabulary that flows like open chords, propelled him into a life few could survive, let alone immortalize. From the age of 16, Given became a one-man crime wave: robbing 75 banks with nothing but a Bic Pen and a smile, inventing the Mercury Bandit invisibility trick with a baby thermometer, dropping through pharmacy roofs with a Superman pillowcase, and running from New Orleans detectives through the French Quarter while dressed as a 70-year-old woman. He served 12 years on a 10-year federal sentence, reading 120 volumes of Supreme Court decisions in the hole and ruling the law library like a throne. He met the devil twice on a dope-sick bed and refused to curse God — only to have angels physically grab his arm and pull him back. His 56+ stories pour out raw, unoutlined, and alive — no MFA polish, no ghostwriter, no filter. The prose is Hemingway-tight yet